Logo graphic



Home
AboutUs
Services
Info
ContactUs


Information graphic

Plan Comparison Information

Our consultants provide clients with assistance in designing, implementing, and administering their retirement programs. A brief overview of several plan types follows. This overview material describes basic benefits, draws attention to critical limitations, and details eligible employee participation. You get a broad look at the way one plan compares to another. Space limitations only allow for the inclusion of minimum information. National Associates consultants remain available to advise on your specific circumstances. Also see below for All Plans Update - Maximum Benefits Limits.

*Note: SIMPLE is an acronym for Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees.


Traditional 401(k)

Benefits

  • Employee pre-tax deferrals up to 100% of compensation or $15,000 1
  • Discretionary employer profit sharing contributions
  • Employee contributions by payroll deductions
  • Possible employer match for employee contributions
  • Available options - loans, vesting, hardship withdrawals, rollovers
  • Protection from creditors

Limitations

  • May prevent maximum deferrals for key employees
  • Anti-discrimination test applies
  • Annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Moderate administrative detail

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21 with one year of service - 1,000 hours

Back to top


Safe Harbor 401(k)

Benefits

  • Employee deferrals up to 100% of compensation or $15,000 1
  • Discretionary employer contributions
  • Employee contributions by payroll deductions
  • Options available - loans, vesting, hardship withdrawals, rollovers
  • Deemed to pass discrimination test
  • May automatically meet top-heavy contribution requirements
  • Protection from creditors

Limitations

  • Annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Moderate administrative detail
  • Requires annual election and notice
  • Mandatory employer contributions

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21 with one year of service - 1,000 hours

Back to top


Profit Sharing

Benefits

  • Individual deduction limit, lesser of 100% or $42,000 2
  • Maximum employer deduction 25% of eligible compensation
  • Discretionary or fixed employer contributions
  • Other options - vesting, withdrawals, rollovers, loans
  • Protection from creditors

Limitations

  • Annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Moderate administrative detail
  • Limited allocation options
  • Salary deferral not allowable

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21 with one year of service, then vesting schedule can apply
  • Age 21 with two years of service, then 100% vested at entry

Back to top


Cross-Tested Profit Sharing
New Comparability

Benefits

  • Target individuals or groups to maximize contributions
  • Maximum employer deduction 25% of compensation
  • Individual contribution limit, lesser of 100% or $42,000 2
  • May combine into a 401(k) plan
  • Other options - vesting, rollovers, loans
  • Protection from creditors

Limitations

  • Annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Extensive administrative detail

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21 with one year of service, then vesting schedule can apply
  • Age 21 with two years of service, then 100% vested at entry

Back to top


Defined Benefit Pension

Benefits

  • Maximize contributions and tax deductions
  • Annual maximum individual benefit payable $170,000 3
  • May credit service prior to plan inception
  • Favorable to older and long tenured employees
  • Protection from creditors

Limitations

  • Recurring annual contribution
  • Annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Extensive administrative detail
  • Actuary advice required

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21 with one year of service, then vesting schedule can apply
  • Age 21 with two years of service, then 100% vested at entry

Back to top


Cash Balance Pension - New Plan Only

Benefits

  • Maximize contributions and tax deductions
  • Annual maximum individual benefit payable $170,000 3
  • May credit service prior to plan inception
  • Favorable to older and long tenured employees
  • Protection from creditors

Limitations

  • Recurring annual contribution
  • Annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Extensive administrative detail
  • Actuary advice required
  • Lump sum distribution upon retirement

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21 with one year of service, then vesting schedule can apply
  • Age 21 with two years of service, then 100% vested at entry

Back to top


Simplified Employee Pension

Benefits

  • Maximum employer deduction lesser of 25% or $42,000 2
  • Flexible contribution amounts
  • No annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Less administrative detail

Limitations

  • No vesting schedule
  • No federal protection from liens
  • No hour requirements

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Age 21
  • Employed three of past five years
  • Compensation at least $450

Back to top


SIMPLE IRA
Savings Incentive Match Plan for Employees

Benefits

  • Employee pre-tax deferrals
  • Employer matching contributions
  • Structured document
  • No annual IRS 5500 Report
  • Less administrative detail
  • Satisfies discrimination/top-heavy testing

Limitations

  • Maximum $10,000 employee deferral 1
  • Mandatory employer contribution
  • No vesting schedule
  • No hour or age requirement
  • Higher withdrawal penalties than qualified plan

Employee Participation - Maximum Requirements

  • Employed past two years
  • Minimum forecasted annual compensation $5,000

Back to top


Notes

  • Note 1 - As of 2005, thereafter inflation adjusted
  • Note 2 - As of 2005, thereafter annually inflation adjusted in $1,000 increments
  • Note 3 - As of 2005, thereafter annually inflation adjusted in $5,000 increments

Back to top


All Plans Update - Maximum Benefits and Contribution Limits

 

2008

2007

2006

Elective Deferrals 401(k), others

$15,500

$15,500

$15,000

Defined Benefit Plans

$185,000

$180,000

$175,000

Defined Contribution Plans

$46,000

$45,000

$44,000

Annual Compensation Limit

$230,000

$225,000

$220,000

Highly Compensated

$105,000

$100,000

$100,000

SIMPLE Retirement Accounts

$10,500

$10,500

$10,000

SEP Coverage (Min Wages)

$500

$500

$450

Social Security Taxable Income

$102,000

$97,500

$94,200

Home page | About Us | Our Services | Information | Contact Us


Material Copyright © 1997-2006 National Associates, Inc., N.W.